Are Roof Shingles Toxic?

Are Roof Shingles Toxic?

Traditional roof shingles have long been the most popular choice for roofing material due to their durability and aesthetic appeal. However, they have come under scrutiny for their environmental and health impact. With the construction industry (as well as consumers) becoming increasingly conscious of the materials it employs, it has become increasingly important to understand the toxicity of the shingles themselves.

The Composition of Roof Shingles

It’s essential to understand the potential for toxicity and the implications for both human health and the environment. Roof shingles come in various materials, including asphalt, wood, metal, slate, and, historically, asbestos. Each material carries its own set of considerations.

Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles are the most prevalent roofing material in the United States due to their cost-effectiveness and ease of installation. They consist of a fiberglass or felt paper base coated with a waterproof layer of asphalt and topped with ceramic granules. While asphalt shingles themselves are not considered toxic, the manufacturing process and the potential for off-gassing volatile organic compounds (VOCs) can be a concern. It’s crucial to ensure proper ventilation to mitigate any potential VOC exposure.

Wood Shingles

Wood shingles, typically made from cedar, redwood, or pine, offer a natural aesthetic and have been a traditional choice for centuries. However, they require treatment with preservatives and flame retardants to enhance durability and safety, which may introduce toxic substances. These treatments can leach over time, necessitating careful handling and disposal.

Metal Shingles

Metal shingles, known for their durability and recyclability, are considered a more environmentally friendly option. They are often made from recycled materials and can be recycled at the end of their life cycle, reducing landfill waste. The primary concern with metal shingles is the potential for lead in older coatings, which is no longer a common practice in manufacturing.

Slate Shingles

Slate shingles are prized for their longevity and natural appearance. Being a natural stone product, slate is inherently non-toxic. However, the mining process has environmental impacts, and the weight of slate roofing requires more structural support, influencing building design and construction.

Historical Use of Asbestos Shingles

Historically, asbestos was a common component in roofing materials due to its fire-resistant properties. However, its use has been dramatically reduced due to the severe health risks associated with asbestos exposure. Asbestos fibers, when inhaled, can lead to serious diseases, including mesothelioma and lung cancer. The American Public Health Association reports that asbestos-related diseases cause an estimated 255,000 deaths each year worldwide, with nearly 40,000 occurring in the United States. Furthermore, the number of malignant mesothelioma deaths in the U.S. increased by 4.8% between 1999 and 2015, underscoring the lethal impact of asbestos exposure.

Modern Innovations and Considerations

In response to the toxic legacy of asbestos, the roofing industry has innovated to develop safer materials that do not compromise on fire resistance or durability. Modern shingles are designed to be less toxic and more sustainable. However, it remains critical for manufacturers and consumers alike to remain vigilant about the materials used in roofing products. The continued importation and use of asbestos in certain industries, despite the known risks, is a contentious issue that underscores the need for strict regulation and oversight.

Manufacturing Process and Potential Toxins in Asphalt Shingles

The manufacturing of asphalt shingles is a high-temperature process where raw materials are transformed into the final product. It begins with a fiberglass mat, to which asphalt is applied, followed by the embedding of ceramic granules. The process involves several chemicals, including adhesives, sealants, and mineral stabilizers.

Potential Toxins

During production, asphalt shingles can emit pollutants, including VOCs, which are a group of chemicals that vaporize at room temperature and can cause short- and long-term health effects. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has identified a range of VOCs emitted from building materials, including asphalt shingles. These emissions can contribute to indoor air quality issues when new roofing materials are stored or installed.

Environmental and Health Concerns

The environmental impact of asphalt shingle production is significant. The high energy consumption required for manufacturing and the emissions from the production process contribute to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions. Furthermore, the disposal of asphalt shingles poses environmental challenges. They are a major contributor to construction waste, and while they are technically recyclable, the actual rates of recycling are low. This leads to millions of tons of shingle waste in landfills each year, where they can potentially leach toxins into the soil and groundwater.

Exposure Risks and Health Implications of Asphalt Shingles

Occupational Exposure

Roofers and construction workers who handle asphalt shingles are at the highest risk of exposure to any toxins present. The cutting, nailing, and removal of shingles can release dust and fibers that may be inhaled, leading to respiratory issues. Adequate protective measures, including respirators and proper ventilation, are crucial to minimize these risks.

Homeowner Exposure

Homeowners may be exposed to toxins from asphalt shingles during installation or renovation projects. The risk is particularly high when shingles are removed during re-roofing, as the process can release dust and particles. Proper disposal and handling techniques are essential to reduce exposure.

Long-Term Health Implications

The long-term health implications of exposure to toxins in asphalt shingles are not fully understood. However, the potential for respiratory problems, skin irritation, and other health issues cannot be ignored. The EPA’s report on indoor air quality indicates that long-term exposure to VOCs can lead to chronic respiratory problems, allergic reactions, and even neurological issues.

Mitigating Risks

To mitigate the risks associated with asphalt shingles, it is essential to follow industry best practices for installation and disposal. This includes using proper personal protective equipment (PPE), ensuring good ventilation, and adhering to guidelines for the safe removal and disposal of old shingles. Additionally, manufacturers are continually working to reduce the VOC emissions from their products, and selecting low-VOC shingles can be a safer choice for both installers and homeowners.

Regulations and Safety Standards for Asphalt Shingles

To address the environmental and health concerns associated with asphalt shingles, various regulations and safety standards have been established. In the United States, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) sets limits on the amount of VOCs that can be emitted from architectural coatings, including those used on asphalt shingles. These regulations are designed to protect air quality and reduce the potential for health risks.

Industry Response to Regulations

The roofing industry has responded to these regulations by developing shingles that comply with or exceed these standards. Manufacturers have reformulated products to lower VOC content and have invested in technologies that capture emissions during the production process. Additionally, there is a growing trend towards the use of more sustainable materials and practices in the roofing industry.

Certification and Eco-Friendly Options

Certifications such as the ENERGY STAR rating for roofing materials indicate compliance with strict energy efficiency guidelines set by the EPA. Moreover, products that carry the Green Seal are recognized for meeting rigorous environmental standards. Homeowners and contractors looking to make eco-friendly choices can look for these certifications when selecting roofing materials.

Best Practices for Handling and Installation

For those in the roofing industry and homeowners considering a roofing project, best practices for handling and installation are critical to minimize exposure to any potential toxins.

Safe Handling

When working with asphalt shingles, it is important to wear gloves and long sleeves to prevent skin contact. If cutting is required, using tools with dust collection features can help reduce inhalation of particles.

Proper Installation

During installation, ensuring good ventilation can help disperse any VOCs that may be released. Following the manufacturer’s guidelines for installation not only ensures the longevity of the roof but also minimizes the release of harmful substances.

Disposal and Recycling

When removing old asphalt shingles, they should be disposed of properly at a facility that can handle construction waste. If recycling options are available, this is the preferred method of disposal to reduce environmental impact.

The Future of Roofing Materials

As we look to the future, the trend is moving towards roofing materials that are both environmentally friendly and pose no health risks. The industry is investing in research and development to find new materials that meet these criteria. The goal is to create roofing options that are sustainable, efficient, and safe for both the installers and the occupants of the buildings they protect.


Get a Free Roofing Estimate